By Iivi Anna Masso, Ph.D., former Advisor to the President (2013-2015), target
I have written essays on my account of what was done to me by the Office of the President of Estonia, with the help of complicit Estonian and Finnish media, back in 2014-2015 when my career was brutally ended through multiple smear campaigns, bullying, mobbing and eventually dismissal. Here is a step further, after extensive professional legal consultancy – indeed, the Office of the President of Estonia, my bosses and colleagues at the time such as Siim Raie, Toomas Hendrik Ilves, Toomas Sildam, Kai Kaarelson and Ülle Madise have directly, totally, blatantly broken both Estonian and international law. My dismissal was entirely illegal by not just one or two, but by several different laws; as was the order, by all of those named above (including the then and now president of Estonia), for me to stay quiet and suffer the sexist, disgusting public (and in-office) humiliation in silence. Below is a thorough description, along with the chronology of facts, of the laws explicitly broken:
The breaches include: Illegal dismissal of a presidential advisor on time-bound contract, masking firing for personal motives/retaliation as “structural reorganisation” or pro-forma “redundancy” (“koondamine” in Estonian); gender discrimination, sexual harassment, workplace mobbing, character assassination, libel, spreading disinformation.
The laws broken: EU Directive 2006/54/EC Equal Opportunities and Equal Treatment in the Workplace, 2(1)(c) Sexual Harassment; 2(2)(a) Retaliation as Discrimination; 24, Victimisation; Directive 2000/78/EC General Framework for Equal Treatment in Employment, art. 2(3) Harassment as Institutional Failure; Estonian Public Service Act, ATS § 90, 97, 103, Employment Contracts Act, TLS §88, 89, 97, Civil Code Act TsÜS §89, Gender Equality Act SoVS §3,5,6,7, Equal Treatment Act VõrdKS 1. §3 (3), the Estonian Constitution §17, UDHR §12.
As Estonia is getting used to its new President, Ülle Madise, appointed into the position by the Parliament without competing candidates or actual elections, her contradictory relationship to the law is quickly revealed to the wider public as on day one in office, she granted her new Director of the Office, Paavo Nõgene, a monthly salary higher than the law allows (8000 Vs. max 6300 €).
Below, I share my experience from the same institution from the time I worked there, for the then President Toomas Hendrik Ilves and with the now President Ülle Madise who served as the legal advisor to President Ilves at the time. As a result of a couple of years of hard work there, my career was abrupted, my name smeared, my reputation destroyed, so that I’ve spent the following years trying to reclaim my dignity and professional status, this far totally in vain. The character assassination campaign that was arranged against me at the time, culminating in the illegal dismissal that gave my reputation the final blow (masked in public as if it was somehow my fault, while formally presenting it as a no-fault objective organisational restructuring), was an ugly incident that has been even called “the most glaring betrayal in modern Estonian political history”, yet it was covered up by absolute media silence, in accordance with the classical strat-com PR rule of “strategical containment”, stonewalling.
Ülle Madise, now the new President and before that the guardian of Estonian justice system as the Chancellor of Justice (2015-2026), was one of the central figures in the crimes committed against me. As President Ilves also went along with the harassment and the illegal “social killing”, I cannot say that Madise is the first President of Estonia with a complicated relationship to the law. Rather, I see a continuity there, a “return to the crime scene” by Madise, or even, a sort of a palace coup that started many years ago, being completed by now.
I have described the character assassination against me that was used to push me out of my workplace and end my career, in Estonian, Finnish and English, just to be met with stonewalling by the media. This account is not a story or a memoire, but a factsheet focusing on law, to indicate how the presidential office, and several of my colleagues there, acted illegally when destroying me; I point out which laws were broken and how. I was never able to take the case to the court, as suing a presidential office by an expelled employee just seemed too overwhelming. Also, with one of the perpetrators as the true “fox in the henhouse”, I had no trust towards the Estonian justice system — in spite of what the laws explicitly and unambiguously say. But with the help of the legal councel currently available, more and more new facts come to daylight, and I do the least I can in the hindsight — that is, make these facts publicly visible.
The Office of the President and the media that it fully controls have done an impressive work hushing up what happened in 2014-15, so much so that one of the perpetrators has been promoted to be not just the guardian of the country’s justice system, but also the head of State — but factual truth has a tendency to be revealed eventually. This document is another little step in that direction. Here I do not attempt to entertain or please the reader, it is not an essay or an article, just a fact-sheet on how exactly my reputation was destroyed and what the European as well as Estonian own laws say about each step on the way.
I have not been heard this far. I have been excluded from the job markets in my field of expertise since this brutal unpersoning through character assassination happened. Along with my reputation, I lost all networks, contacts, everything that used to connect me to my professional identity during and long before my work in the presidential Castle. My attempts to tell what actually happened and to restore my dignity have been dismissed as just whining by an embittered former employee, or a personal conflict between colleagues; in a true strat-com spirit, whatever I say has been dismissed as totally irrelevant. Yet I keep writing as I know that the truth, the laws, and the values that Estonia and Europe claim to represent — such as human rights, equality and dignity — are on my side.
I do not think that Estonia can become a real democracy as long as such Soviet style “enemy-making” incidents still happen, and the media acts in perfect symbiosis with the cynical state bureaucracy, first executing the character assassination, then covering up what happened and totally silencing the target; as long as the victims of such campaigns get destroyed and the perpetrators are rewarded at the highest level.
As always: all written materials I refer to have been preserved and are available at request. The oral statements I refer to are based on my diary notes as well as memory. I am always willing to provide more information to anyone who is genuinely interested in the case.
And here follows the legal analysis of what happened in 2014-15:
I worked as an advisor to the President of Estonia, Toomas Hendrik Ilves, from January 1, 2013. My contract was temporary for nearly four years, until the end of Ilves’s term, October 10, 2016. The Director of the Office of the President at the time was Siim Raie.
My task was to help the President to prepare his texts, speeches and statements, both spoken and written, both in Estonian and in English. As for the President’s feedback for my work, it was only ever very positive.
On April 15, 2014 I received an e-mail from a Jaanus Hämarsoo, a reporter at Kroonika, a glossy gossip magazine belonging to the powerful Estonian media corporation Ekspress Grupp. He asked me to “confirm” the “information” they allegedly had, that I was “close” to my boss, President Ilves, beyond work; he asked me directly if I was having an affair with him. I consulted, as you’re supposed to, President Ilves’s media advisor Toomas Sildam asking if I need to reply to such absurdity. Sildam told me to reply very lightly. I replied, however, that the question offended me as well as the President’s family; I reminded the paper they were legally responsible for what they would claim in public.
On April 17, 2014 Kroonika published a cover story in which President Ilves’s marriage to his wife Evelin Ilves was claimed to be in “crisis”. The magazine painted me as the “femme fatale” guilty for the split, wrote about a “love triangle” and gave a very clear impression that I was having an affair with my boss. This totally fabricated libel was repeated in even stronger terms by Elu24, the gossip webpage of Postimees, the biggest daily in Estonia belonging to the second large private media corporation, Postimees Grupp. The author of the story was Anu Saagim. Postimees headlined the libelous story by hinting to a “sizzling love affair” between me and the President. The only source for both of these simultaneously fabricated stories was anonymous “people close to the President”.
The Office of the President (abbr. below OP) did not react to those “news” at all, even as otherwise Sildam had a habit of contacting the media to correct any false information published. We used to have meetings to discuss media coverage when the President wasn’t happy with it — now, silence. No reactions at all, just belittling, laughing it off, by some colleagues.
President Ilves himself never reacted to the story and never talked to me about it.
Sildam commented the attack in a way that revealed that he had been aware of it coming. In the hindsight, I know that those media would never have dared to publish this kind of a campaign without Sildam’s complicity.
The legal advisor to President Ilves at the time, Ülle Madise, told me I should be flattered for such an attention by the media — for them presenting an image of me as “fuckable”. A similar comment also came from Siim Raie, the Director. The Office did nothing to refute the false rumor in the media. On the contrary — they made it clear to me that I was not allowed to react, either publicly or through courts. Self-defense was prohibited for me.
What does the law say about such a situation?
Estonia had been a member of the European Union for nearly 10 years at the time. It was obliged to follow EU’s directives and laws. The gender equality directives (2006/54/EC Equal Opportunities and Equal Treatment in the Workplace; 2000/78/EC General Framework for Equal Treatment in Employment), as well as Estonia’s own equal treatment and gender equality laws (SoVS 1. §3 3), 5) ja 6); §5 (1); §6 (2) 7); VõrdKS 1. §3, (3)) clearly forbid sexual harassment in a workplace. That does not only mean unwanted physical advances. The law defines harassment as a situation”where any form of unwanted verbal, non-verbal or physical conduct of a sexual nature occurs, with the purpose or effect of violating the dignity of a person, and of creating an intimidating, hostile, degrading, humiliating or offensive environment.” Legal experts clearly classify the situation where a female employee is publicly labeled the boss’s mistress and the workplace tolerates or even encourages it, as well as Madise’s sexist, degrading remarks, as harassment defined by the law. And it is illegal to prevent an employee from resisting or protesting against such situations, and punishing them if they do so — that, in turn, qualifies as discrimination based on sex. The laws are clear that no employer has a right to force an employee to endure such a hostile environment, created by the rumours and comments.
It is a common misunderstanding that sexual harassment requires physical advances or an actual sexual relationship used against an employee. The laws clearly include as harassment the creating of a hostile environment based on sex, also by non-physical means. Generating, distributing, or validating explicit sexual rumors about a female employee to undermine her professional standing perfectly fits the definition of creating a hostile work environment based on sex.
When the media presents a highly qualified, serious and respected female civil servant as simply her VIP boss’s sex object in the eyes of the public or hints that she has reached her position through sexual services, it is explicit sexualised degradation and a massive attack on the target’s professional reputation and dignity. The toxic effect of this situation is further enhanced when it is related to work and the workplace does nothing to counteract it. It is even worse when the very people who should be proactive in counteracting such offenses, such as Director Raie and legal advisor Madise, aggravate the humiliation by in-office sexist put-downs in vulgar, abusive language. And it is beyond tolerable when the degrading rumours have been fed to the media deliberately by those same colleagues, and the superiors as well as colleagues not just fail to support the target but explicitly ban her from defending herself.
Given the information gathered this far it is well established that the abusive false rumors were fed to the media by President Ilves’s media advisor Toomas Sildam, his legal advisor Ülle Madise and his foreign policy advisor Kai Kaarelson, with the possible contribution of part-time advisor Olari Koppel, external media consultant Raul Rebane and journalist Urve Eslas. Their role in the smear campaign has been revealed first of all by their own reactions and comments, but also subsequent leaks in-office and from the media. A “who benefits” is also helpful — Madise, who dreamed of presidency early on, may have wanted to eliminate the person whom Ilves mentioned as his preferred presidential “heiress”; Kaarelson tried to achieve full control of Ilves’s foreign policy voice, Eslas took over the position of the advisor to Ilves after his term’s end. Sildam and Rebane were the master manipulators of the media, making sure that president Ilves’s relationship with high level Latvian official Ieva Kupce wouldn’t become public before President Ilves’s and Evelin Ilves’s divorce and a controlled introduction through a calculated PR-operation.
I’d like to emphasize that sexualized smear campaigns, or operations labeling the targeted people sexually deviant or morally corrupt, in order to destroy their societal position, human dignity and professional reputation, is not a new or original media tactics. It was a standard tactics by the likes of the KGB in the Soviet Union, to eliminate unwanted intellectuals who offered no excuses to eliminate them from society by their own actions. It is an efficient way to wipe away a person’s professional standing overnight – the target loses their credibility, it becomes hard for them to be taken seriously as professionals.
Because the OP did not react to the smear campaign – just by further humiliating the target –, it is a fair diagnosis that from April 17, 2014 on the work environment there became hostile and degrading — not just by my personal assessment, but in accordance with the legal definition of harassment. I endured it for nearly a year. Defying Raie’s orders to not react at all, I contacted the editors publishing the false, libelous rumors. The responsible publisher of Postimees Mart Luik admitted in an e-mail four days after they published the lies, April 21, 2014, that he knew they had published false information. But he refused to publish a rebuttal, blaming Kroonika for bringing up the gossip first. It is stated in the Code of Ethics for the Estonian press that once false information has been published, the correction must be published as visibly and by the same forum. Luik (who today sits on the board of the Estonian national public broadcaster ERR), as well as the editor-in-chief or Postimees, Merit Kopli and the author of the hit piece Anu Saagim, all were consciously and deliberately violating the ethics code as well as Postimees Grupp’s own ethics statement. The same can be said about the editor-in-chief of Kroonika, Krista Lensin, who replied to my protests by nothing but extreme, derisive arrogance.
By the time Postimees removed their libelous story from the web, it had already traveled to dozens of other, smaller papers who kept it online for so long that even a year later when I googled my name, the results were pages of stories about me as the President’s “mistress”. Even as many Estonians, especially colleagues who knew us personally, said “no one would believe the gossip pages’ rumors anyway”, it is hard to overestimate the damage such degrading publicity does to a member of the President’s professional team.
This is exactly what the law means by hostile, degrading environment, and those guilty of creating it were the media as well as the OP — but also, given the high profile and wide publicity of the libel, other media that did not directly participate in it, but did not oppose it either — such as ERR. This situation underlines the difference between a society like the USA, where similar degrading allegations against Nikki Haley as president Donald Trump’s alleged mistress in 2018 were univocally condemned and refuted by the media across the political spectrum as unacceptable attempts to smear a woman professional. No such protests were forthcoming in Estonia. In Estonia, a smeared woman is on her own.
As the smear campaign remained lingering without any public refuttal, the work environment in the OP became increasingly toxic. It was meant to be so — the goal clearly was to eliminate me. An obvious reason I was a target was that I was an outsider, having studied and worked abroad, interrupting with certain gatekeepers’ “ownership” of the President and his public messages, defending the president’s own thoughts and voice. Another reason was, as mentioned above, that president Ilves named me at ERR’s public debate with challenger Indrek Tarand before his re-election in August 2011, when asked whom he would like to see as his follower after the second term. That clearly made me a target in the eyes of the most jealous colleagues before I even worked at the OP.
The OP repeatedly warned me to not defend myself against the libel — in clear violation of the gender equality laws as well as the Constitution. Those warnings came in both in writing and orally. The first written warning came from foreign policy advisor Kai Kaarelson in a long e-mail sent at night, April 29 2014, just a couple of weeks after the initial libel campaign was published. Kaarelson attacked me because I had taken distance from the media rumours in the OP’s general e-mail-list; I suggested we should find out where the false rumours came from. “You have no enemies, but by doing this you create some sooner or later,” Kaarelson insisted, among many other equally intimidating statements. At the same time at work, Kaarelson aggressively tried to censor president Ilves’s Russia-critical talks.
The oral warnings against me resisting the media rumours came from Raie right after their publication, later also from Sildam, Madise and Maimu Sibrits, the assistant of Mrs. Evelin Ilves. Later I received written commands to shut up and not defend my dignity from president Ilves himself, and from Raie again right before my dismissal, accompanied by a direct threat to fire me if I do not shut up. Sildam insisted that the anonymous people “close to the president” whom the press quoted as their sources, “did not exist”; Sibrits told me to “not fight the UFOs” and a HR clerk, Mailis Neppo, warned me on November 12, 2014 that my “public hanging” was being prepared. When I asked president Ilves by e-mail what that meant, he replied (by e-mail) that I had nothing to fear as I did my work well. In the hindsight, that too appears as a piece of gaslighting.
In the winter of 2015 the libel campaign that the OP never agreed to refute, reached Finland where my husband’s family lived, and where I was going to look for my next job after Ilves’s term would end. On January 31, 2015 a well known Finnish Estonia hater Sami Lotila published a blog text full of angry, abusive Kremlin-style hatred against Estonian foreign policy leaders and me personally. Among other abuse — e.g. he called the President a CIA-agent and the foreign minister his “arse-licker” — Lotila labeled me the President’s “girlfriend” again, referring to the Estonian media as his source and hinting that I was professionally lousy, just taken to Estonia and my advisor position as the “girlfriend”. Interpreted in legal terms, the environment of sexual harassment expanded to the international arena and to my home environment where I needed to find my next job.
The Estonian media was also to be blamed for this — they offered the professional slanderer the abuse against me on a platter. Lotila’s smear was enhanced by Risto Vuorinen, a freelance correspondent of Finland’s public broadcaster Yle, who shared it on his Facebook page on February 2, 2015, praising it as “good analysis” on Estonia. Doing so, Vuorinen violated Finland’s journalist guidelines as well as Yle’s own social media rules — which require that a journalist control his facts, keep the style respectable and in case of targeting specific persons in a negative light, include the target’s point of view.
As the only way for me to respond was to use my own social media platforms, I warned my friends about Vuorinen in Facebook and Twitter, told them that he was spreading Kremlin style propaganda and that it would be better to ignore him, should he ask for an interview. This launched the second part of the massive smear campaign against me — now I was accused of attacking a poor Finnish journalist. It was framed as a “free speech scandal” and even as a “diplomatic scandal” between Finland and Estonia. Even though I made it very clear in the discussion that followed that I had referred to Vuorinen’s shares on social media, the entire incident was presented as if I had just attacked a journalist for his work, from a position of power, unprovoked. Indeed the unprovoked attack came from him against me. What he did, in the guise of the undoubtedly Kremlinite rhetoric, was to pick up and repeat the same sexualized, degrading slander that the Estonian media had started. It was Vuorinen’s boss at Yle, the head of world news Elina Ravantti who initially did the magic trick of reversal — instead of reproaching her reporter for breaching Yle’s social media rules and basic journalist ethics, she attacked me, defending her libel boys.
I was now painted in public as the enemy of free speech, the enemy of Finland and a diplomatic liability that the presidential castle just had to get rid of. On the Estonian side, my colleague Sildam made sure that the press presented it the same way Ravantti did.
What happened here was a very professional communications strategy, DARVO — Deny, Attack, and Reverse Victim and Offender. The two men who launched an unprovoked libelous smear campaign against me were presented as victims of a tyrannic silencer, and I was turned into an offender, as I, for the first time after the smear campaign had been going on for nearly a year, had publicly resisted it in a brief critical social media comment. This is how it remained, in spite of all my efforts to set things right — the vile, ugly, low-style aggressive and abusive disinformation attack by the two freelance correspondents was hidden in plain sight, while my brief and relatively modest response to it was presented as an “attack against a journalist” — it is how you see it until this day if you google the issue, or ask any AI source. Only deeper questioning that presumes prior knowledge, opens more truthful analysis of the case from the web of collective knowledge.
So in the eyes of the public, I was once again re-labeled as an alleged “mistress” or “girlfriend” of my boss, the President, and now also labeled a “diplomatic problem”, a liability. It was here that the insiders of the presidential castle — Madise, Kaarelson, Raie and Sildam — acted to finally eliminate me. This was the endgame of the “public hanging” that Neppo had miraculously predicted months before the second smear campaign started.
In all this noise, the message that I was strictly forbidden to clearly express in public, was simply that I was not my boss’s mistress, never had been, and labeling me as such had been and was wrong, both factually and morally. As simple as that. And that was exactly what I was not allowed to say. Saying it anyway became my ultimate crime.
The law is clear on this: a female employee has the right to defend her honor, dignity and good name against a sexualized smear campaign labeling her the boss’s mistress. When an employer punishes or dismisses her for defending herself in such a situation, they plainly violate the laws of gender equality and the principles of equal treatment. Any such punishment qualifies as direct sex discrimination. This didn’t stop Raie, Ilves, Madise and others. They started to blame me for “defending my own interests” and through that, “spoiling the reputation of the president’s office” through my self-defense.
President Ilves sent me his last ever e-mail on February 9, 2015, while being at the Munich security conference with Kaarelson and her newly hired assistant, Liis Lipre-Järma (whom president Madise now hired as her foreign policy advisor). He said (my translation): “Iivi, I know how important your good name and the freedom or speech is for you. The truth is also important to me” — and he went on, probably under a strong influence by Kaarelson, talking about a “diplomatic crisis” and claiming my “statements” might hurt the relationships between Estonia and Finland (that is, “statements” in which I criticized the lies and abuse by a couple of freelance bloggers!) He wrote that he understood I was under attack. But he demanded: “Stop this discussion, please. Don’t react publicly to these attackers. /…/ I have enough problems on other fronts.” Thus the President of Estonia also directly ignored the constitutional right of his advisor to defend herself against sexualized smear, just asking the target to shut up because he had more important problems than her human and professional dignity.
By mid-February 2015 I was being ostracized at my workplace to the degree that I was literally treated as if I didn’t exist. One of the persons behaving like this was Ülle Madise. My name was written in the President’s calendar as the advisor responsible for the February 24 Independence Day speech. The meetings preparing the speech were held behind my back. Madise, who had already been nominated to start in her new role of the Chancellor of Justice soon, acted as if she was in charge of the speech, without telling me why. I later found out why — she knew what she was planning with Raie and Sildam.
After the Independence Day, on February 26 2015, I received an e-mail from Siim Raie, in which he expressed similar indifference towards the female employee’s dignity as the President, but he also added direct attacks and threats to fire me: “I understand that you have decided to continue defending your interests in public”, he wrote, referring to a little piece in Delfi written about a media-critical comment of mine in a private facebook conversation. Raie went on: “Your actions harm the reputation and activities of the President. /…/ The situation is not acceptable. /…/ If personal opinions and their impact are not compatible with your work duties or start to harm your employer, you must end either expressing the opinions or your work contract. The choice is yours.” I emphasise that what Raie meant by “my interests” still was my “interest” to not be slandered in public as my boss’s mistress. The interest to finally end the degrading campaign of character assassination that had been going on for a year. The “unacceptable situation” Raie referred to was something that neither Raie, legal advisor Madise, media advisor Sildam nor president Ilves himself had seen any need to end. Thus Raie, like the President a couple of weeks earlier, clearly forbade my public self-defense. Raie taking it a step further, bringing in direct threats about my position at work.
I replied on February 27, 2015, to Raie as well as the President. I referred to the ongoing extreme aggression by Ekspress Grupp that was very active in the disinformation operation against me from the very beginning to the very end. I actually had not given any statements to the media for a while, they grabbed their headlines from my private Facebook-discussions in which I just agreed with some other people criticizing the media.
I wrote: “What do you mean by “defending my interests” — replying to the libel? /…/ I will gladly discuss the conditions of the continuation of my work contract. Let us start by clarifying thoroughly, what brought us to this situation today: where did the fabricated gossip about my and the president’s alleged affair come from, who needed that? Why didn’t you ever think that that campaign harmed the president? Why do I hear from so many different sources that those rumors were spread by the staff of our own office? Why did Sildam know about the media campaign in advance, while I myself did not? Why did Kaarelson send me a 9000-character threatening e-mail at night, when I politely distanced myself from the gossip? /…/
In whose interest is it to mob out an advisor who has done good work, smear her reputation by public lies, spoil her working relations with the president and destroy her future?
These are the questions I’d like to have thourough answers to, when starting to talk about my work contract. When all that will be clarified, then we can go on talking about news headlines based on facebook discussions, the yellow press having their day /…/ Could be that this is willingly used as an excuse for lynching.”
The response by Raie was waiting for me after the weekend, on Monday, March 2 2015. With the help of legal advisor Madise he had prepared documents about “restructuring” the office so that my job disappeared. Raie, with Neppo also in the room after a regular Monday morning meeting, asked me to sign the papers, threatening me by force — precisely, by throwing me out of the house by force using the armed guards watching the Castle — if I refuse. I should not have signed. I didn’t know the law was explicitly on my side in many ways. The Office of the President, its Director, was acting in direct, explicit, unambiguous violation of several Estonian and European laws, and the dismissal was not just totally illegal, it was legally invalid. I didn’t know it, even as I had a very strong hunch that what was happening could not be right. I had no chance of legal councel or a phone call — as even criminals are entitled to when indicted. I was scared of those people. I didn’t dare to not sign.
What does the law say about the dismissal in question?
The e-mail exchange referred above indicate unambiguously that the employer, represented by Siim Raie and Toomas Hendrik Ilves, was clearly aware that I was trying to defend my good name and dignity against the libelous smear. They both explicitly told me not to do it, Raie threatened me with dismissal if I still try to do it. Also in my reply I underlined that the “situation” that Raie described as unacceptable, was caused by the initial smear campaign that hadn’t ended, but escalated as a result of their chosen response — silence.
The Constitution, human rights, EU directives, laws on gender equality and equal treatment are all unanimous on this: sexualised, degrading libel that reduces a female employee to a “mistress” and whose continued presence the employer tolerates or even encourages, is classified as sexual harassment. An employee has the right to defend herself against sexual harassment. Punishing an employee for exercising this right is classified by law as sex discrimination. Dismissing an employee for protesting against harassment is not allowed by law.
The Estonian Gender equality law Soolise võrdõiguslikkuse seadus (SoVS) applies to the case as follows:
SoVS § 3 lg 1 p 4, 5 (Degradation based on sex): The law defines as sex degradation any activity that creates a humiliating or offensive environment. When an institution turns against a woman who is victimised in a media attack instead of supporting her, this counts as persecution by the state.
(SoVS) § 5 lg 1 (Discrimination based on sex): Direct or indirect discrimination of a person based on her sex is forbidden. The label of “the boss’s mistress” followed by pressure by the employer directly offends a woman’s dignity on the basis of her sex.
SoVS § 6 lg 2 p 3 (The obligations of the employer): Punishing a female employee (dismissal) because sexualized libel has been published about her is seen by the law as direct gender discrimination. This is explicitly forbidden by the law.
SoVS § 7 (Retaliation and victimisation as discrimination): The employer is not allowed to disfavor or dismiss an employee because of defending her rights or her dignity.
SoVS § 13: The employee has a right to demand that the employer compensate both the material and immaterial damages, including the hurt against her dignity and reputation.
All this has been written in the Estonian laws since 2009. It was the law also in 2015.
Scared, humiliated, tortured by the long lasting public degradation and workplace mobbing and with no one around to give me legal advice, I was not in a position to pay enough attention to what the law actually said in this situation. Later I was discouraged by the subsequent financial pressure, and by my mistrust towards the justice system now guarded by Ülle Madise, one of the participants in the entire campaign. Also for an expelled employee suing the office of the President is kind of overwhelming. This is exactly what they counted on. But nothing prevents things from becoming public — the human dignity of a person has no sell-by date, it is never too late to tell it as it was.
The Office of the President as an employer, Siim Raie as its director, Toomas Hendrik Ilves as the President and my direct boss, Ülle Madise as the legal advisor, Kai Kaarelson as my colleague, all of them who participated in my humiliation directly or indirectly, they all violated the laws quoted above — some of them by initiating the character assassination, some by allowing it to go on and refusing to stop it, forcing me to quietly endure the hostile environment, threatening me, telling me to stay silent, adding to the degradation by their own sexist, abusive remarks and in the end, by planning and executing the “structural reorganisation” forcing me out of my workplace as a punishment for my attempts to defend my honour and dignity myself. Also possibly participating in the operation were Urve Eslas and Raul Rebane who were sitting with president Ilves upstairs in his office while I was physically expelled from my workplace, escorted out of the house like a criminal.
But gender discrimination wasn’t the only violation of the law during the incident.
The Estonian Public Service Act (§ 90) and Civil Code Act (TsÜS § 89) clearly state that an employee cannot be dismissed through “structural reorganisation” (or “redundancy”, in Estonian “koondamine”) when the employer has expressed a wish to get rid of the particular employee in question — redundancy can only be an objective ground for dismissal, for reasons depending on the employer, such as economic reasons or genuine structural reorganisation. “Structural reasons” are required to have objective grounds which the employer must prove. It is explicitly forbidden by law to use this formal mode to expel an unwanted employee. When there is proof that the employer has wanted to fire a particular person, the “redundancy” is considered pro-forma and thus legally invalid.
In addition, the law does not recognize the “redundancy” dismissal without informing the target in advance, with immediate effect. There is an eventual “loophole” that the OP used, that allows eliminating a position rather than a person through structural reorganisation — but even then, the same rules apply. A position cannot be eliminated unless the employer can prove that the work no longer needs to be done — redistributing the work to others is not allowed. With my name in the President’s calendar far into the ongoing year, e.g. as the advisor responsible for the speech at the UNGA in September, it was obvious that the work had not disappeared. Also, just as with the “redundancy” of persons, the format cannot be used pro-forma, in order to get rid of a particular employee.
But this is exactly what the Office of the President did. My work did not disappear, it was redistributed to others. That is illegal. Also, in case of structural reorganisation the employee must be informed in advance, in my case of 30 days; ending a temporary contract also requires that the “redundant” employee be paid for the rest of the contract. None of the articles of the law was followed. I got no prior warning, I got just two months’ salary as “blood money”, I was stopped in a cellar and forced by threat of violence to sign the papers immediately, then leave the building, escorted out like a criminal.
Such immediate dismissal is allowed by the law only in case of a very grave disciplinary violation by the employee — and then it cannot be formulated as “structural reorganisation”; a written complaint about the employee’s behavior must be presented, she must offer a written explanation and then a thorough investigation must precede the dismissal. Nothing like that, of course, happened. There was no violation on my part (“Defending my interests” as stated by Raie didn’t qualify as such, as defending your honor against smear is a legal right), not in reality, not on paper, but nonetheless I was expelled immediately, in the middle of my contract and a work day, no prior warning.
Given my right to defend myself, Raie’s e-mail from February 26, 2015 qualifies as an illegal threat. In it he blamed me for “harming the President’s reputation” — notably, Raie never thought that the smear campaign about the President having an affair with an employee harmed the President’s reputation, only my protests against it. What Raie claimed I was doing wrong gave him no ground whatsoever for disciplinary action or punishment — which he knew, therefore using the pro-forma, invalid by law, “reorganisation” to push me out. Thus, the Director of the Office of the President of Estonia clearly violated the law, not just by gender discrimination, punishing a female employee for speaking out against sexual harassment, but also by issuing illegal threats and following them directly, executing an illegal and invalid form of dismissal.
So in fact Raie’s threatening e-mail is the best proof against the legality of the “redundancy” — Raie clearly expressed a threat to fire me if I do not shut up. Given the existence of such a written threat sent just three days before the actual expulsion, there is undisputable proof that the “structural reorganisation” was used illegally as a smokescreen for getting rid of a particular employee. In such a situation it is impossible for the employer prove that the reorganisation follows real structural needs, and no proof of the necessity of such a reorganisation was ever presented. Thus in the light of both the gendered nature of the entire conflict, and the written proof of Raie’s antipathy towards an employee, my dismissal was illegal in many ways, by several laws.
This takes us back to Ülle Madise who, as the legal advisor, obviously prepared the “structural reorganisation” papers, either not knowing they were illegal, which is hardly credible, or counting on other parties not knowing it, which is more likely, even if extremely cynical. It is cynical even against Raie — he would have been blamed, had I had the resources to sue. Madise was not my superior. She just prepared the papers, eliminating my position, hoping that it would go through — and it did.
But even if it is too late to sue now, it’s never too late to show in public that what they did was illegal by Estonia’s own laws. Estonia thus got a Chancellor of Justice who was literally a fox in the henhouse – a guardian of the Constitution who breaks the law.
Three people in the President’s office — Kai Kaarelson with her night-time threatening e-mails, Toomas Hendrik Ilves with his order for me to shut up and not defend my good name, Siim Raie in this threatening e-mail right before the illegal pro-forma “redundancy” dismissal, had given me written orders to stay silent and not protest against the smear. In addition, I got oral warnings from Sildam, Madise and Sibrits. There is no doubt whatsoever that the office was aware of the smear campaign’s role as the toxifier of our work environment, but no one cared about either the law or the dignity of a coworker.
Ülle Madise started as the Chancellor of Justice on March 31, 2015, 28 days after my illegal pro-forma “redundancy” expulsion. Two weeks later, April 14, 2015, her part-time colleague Olari Koppel was hired as the Director of the office of the Chancellor of Justice — with no education or experience in law at all. April 6 2015, Siim Raie started in his new role as the Director General of the National Heritage Board, in a field that he studied at the side of his work at the OP but in which he had not a day of experience. For some reason they were in an extreme hurry to eliminate me before moving on to their subsequent high profile positions. The media never investigated why. And they never investigated how, by which qualifications, they all won their high positions through top level competition.
The President’s Office and the wider networks of the state that have been involved in the events mentioned here, have been guarding the media publicity with amazing perfection afterwards. The media has followed the strategic communications rulebook that builds a wall of silence around the illegal actions within a high state institution with admirable precision; or if they must, they diminish my comments as “private conflicts between colleagues”, “the embitterment of one insignificant ex-employee” or just a story too old to be interesting to anyone anymore. Today, as one of those participating in this illegal operation returned to the Palace as the President, the topic is as relevant as ever.
I have the written records, including e-mails that I refer to, well preserved and I am willing to share them when needed. Also, this timeframe leaves out a lot of details and comments; I’d be glad to offer more information at request. Also, as the line on “attacking a journalist” is being promoted as the main “real reason” for my dismissal in the hindsight (also strongly visible in web searches and AI materials), I emphasize that this too was an information operation designed to justify my expulsion whose actual motive was to prevent me from finding out that it indeed were my own colleagues who fed the smear campaign to the media — all lines of my own research lead to this conclusion. Thus I would also be gladly willing to clarify that incident, and offer any investigative journalist the writings by the Finnish journalists that I commented on in 2015 — they are available online, and in my archives, in Finnish. Anyone knowing anything about propaganda and disinformation recognises the nature of those writings.